The 1000-Day CEO · Interview
Most companies say they hire for character. Then they let a résumé decide who gets through the door. What talent are they missing? JR Butler joins Bill Canady o
This episode of The 1000-Day CEO with Bill Canady is mirrored here for The 80/20 Institute audience. The canonical episode (full transcript + player) lives on 1000dayceo.com.
Transcript (extract)
Bill Canady: Hello everyone, it's great to be with you today. I'm Bill Canady on the 1000 Day CEO. Most companies say they hire for character, yet they screen almost always entirely just for credentials. J.R. Butler built shift group around a different question. How do you identify resilience, coachability, curiosity, and team first drive before someone has the resume to prove it? Today's guest, J.R. Butler, is the CEO of the Shift Group, a talent platform that helps former athletes and military veterans transition into business careers. He played Division I hockey at Holy Cross before building a career in technology sales He has held leadership roles at Turbonomic before the acquisition by IBM and later served as Chief Revenue Officer for Pillir He shifted Shift Group around the belief that conventional hiring often overlooks the qualities that ultimately determine performance. Today we'll discuss how CEOs can recognize that talent. evaluated and create an organization where it succeeds. JR, welcome to the 1000 Day CEO.
JR Butler: Pumped to be here, Bill. Thank you for having me.
Bill Canady: You know, I tell you what, we were just chatting before we got on the air. You and I have so much in common. Now, if you if you're a terrible guest, I'm gonna deny anything I just said. But I am going with sports and and veterans are one of my most favorite things. And how we identify and elevate talent is right in the heart of
JR Butler: Yes, sir. A hundred percent. It's the most important part of it, in my opinion.
Bill Canady: Well let's just start off with the background. So hockey was a major part of your identity. When your playing career ended, What did you lose besides the opportunity to compete?
JR Butler: I mean, you know, people use words like identity and purpose, and and they talk about structure. one of the things, you know, sitting sitting here 20 years from from when I stopped playing hockey, I think there's like three there's three core things that I lost that are, you know, they're they're the reason I ended up in a division one locker room. And I think they're the reason that anybody ends up achieving their goals and being successful. The number one thing I lost is like I was so clear, Bill, for 24 years of my life on exactly what I wanted and why I wanted it. I grew up in a house, my father's a Hall of Fame high school and junior hockey coach in Massachusetts. My two younger brothers also played college hockey. One of them was an Olympian and played in the NHL. and what I can tell you is from like six years old to twenty-four years old, every single day I woke up, I my my number one thought was like, how can I How can I get better at hockey? Cause I want to play professionally. so that clarity of vision when when when you number one, you you don't hit necessarily hit that goal, but you wake up the next day, literally, and you're not a hockey player anymore, that goes away. Like you don't know what you want anymore, right? it's the only thing you think about. It's the first and last thing you think about. And that was that was the hardest part, one of the hardest parts of that that I lost when I lost hockey. The second thing. what sports and and and service gives you, because we were just talking about this, like you have to be self aware as an athlete and a service member. Meaning you live in a feedback loop, right? if you suck at something, you you know about it, right? Like your leadership tell you like you talked about getting yelled at all the time. I always tell people like I tell people all the time, I'm like, my dad only speaks in feedback. Like that is his that is his language, right? So like
Bill Canady: His love language.
JR Butler: Yeah, exactly. so you know your strengths, you know your weaknesses, you know what gives you energy, you know what takes it away. It's like you know who you are, and then you wake up one day and you don't. Like, you know, the fact that I had a good slap shot was irrelevant on you know, June first, two thousand and and eight. Like it didn't matter anymore. That was the only thing I knew. You know what I mean? so that like clarity of self gone. out the door. and then the third thing. was I had the playbook my entire life. I knew what I needed to do every single day when I woke up to achieve what I wanted to become. I you know, and and it's not easy, right? Playing college sports is hard. Only two and a half percent of the entire college population does it. But the playbook is is clear. Like you know exactly what you need to get good at. You know exactly how to get good at it. And I think the military is very similar where Hey, you want to go be this? Here's all here's the requirements. Here's what you got to do. Here's the things. that the business world is not like that. It's very opaque. There's a lot of different pathways to get to achieve certain goals, right? Talk you talk to CEOs all the time. They all got there differently. I got here differently. So that loss of playbook, so you lose or that clarity of playbook. So you lose your vision, you lose your identity and and your knowledge of who you are, and you lose the playbook. And it took me several years to like get those things back for my professional career. And those are not easy things to do. So, you know, people talk about they use big fluffy words, but I think those three things are the core to what allows you to do really hard shit all the time when you're in uniform. And business is a lot of really hard shit you don't want to do too. and the only way you're gonna do it is if you get those three things back full stop. So that's like the whole thesis behind the company.
Bill Canady: That makes a lot of sense. You know, let's dig in a little bit. You discovered technology sales almost by accident. What made you realize that the qualities developed in hockey could translate into your business?
JR Butler: by doing it, by doing the business, right? Like you said it. I tripped and fell into it, dude. I was a sociology major with a minor in art history and sign language. And I entered and I yeah, exactly. and I entered
Bill Canady: I shouldn't be laughing. It's like you can do anything with that. That's it.
JR Butler: You can do anything, but also nothing with that.
Bill Canady: Nothing. Absolutely nothing. That's a good rich man's degree, so you need to be born well.
JR Butler: Yeah, exactly. It's well it's you know, that's like liberal arts to a degree, which…
